This is sort of a follow on to a series of posts I gave up on called Windows Vista: Pretty But Underwhelming. After a number of months of playing with it and really trying to use it, I have come to a conclusion.
I don’t like it.
Am I old-fashioned? Are the operating systems of the future too much for me? I have a number of philosophical problems for not liking Vista (DRM, product activation, copying Apple), but I’m willing to put those aside for the sake of fairly appreciating the new user experience. It’s a pretty big step, this new Areo Glass UI, it’s the part of the OS that ultimately matters to the regular joe.
I just don’t like it.
—–
I’m writing a blog post in my head as I try lamely to use Vista on a new laptop. After nearly an hour with the laptop, I keep thinking over and over that I don’t understand how users put up with it. I honestly don’t. Pre-installed on a typical computer Vista is this visually cluttered, sluggish disaster. Slow doesn’t even begin to describe it. This is a brand new laptop with a gigabyte of RAM and a 1.8GHz processor and it takes four minutes to get started. My five year old Windows XP box takes 35 seconds. Same box under Fedora Core Linux, 25 seconds.
Four minutes to started. Or at least I think it’s started. I can never be sure because the hard drive light never stops flashing. It doesn’t. Even when “loaded” Vista is always hacking on the hard drive. As an experienced user, I look to the hard drive as a kind of indicator that something I clicked on is now happening. With Vista, you never know. It’s not like that little swirling circle tells you anything about whether the program you wanted is actually loading. One of things I find myself doing is highlighting something and then pressing the enter key. Why? Because I could never be sure if the double tap on the touch pad had actually took. This leads to accidentally launching two copies of something because after 30 seconds of nothing you usually conclude that you didn’t double-tap fast enough so you double tap again.
Part of the reason the laptop is so slow is because it is filled to the gills with dumb Lenovo shit. Seven different pieces of software, none of which are needed! Commercial offers. Customer care. Update thinger. A little bugger that puts an icon in the system tray and I have no idea what it does. Worse, there’s a trial copy of Norton Internet Security. The biggest, fattest, slowest piece of software ever invented by mankind. I don’t know about you, but I consider having to wait a full minute to bring up the Norton control center thing to be absolutely ridiculous. The removal of Norton takes — and I’m not kidding here — 22 minutes, frees up 250MB of hard drive space and shaves an entire minute off of the system bootup time. It took less time to download and install AVG Antivirus than it took to remove NIS. Unreal.
Now with the system somewhat responsive, I must contend with Vista itself. As I said before, I tried to like the new UI, I really tried, but after working with Vista for a few months I have concluded that it sucks. Some of the elements are pretty, but stick them all together and you have yourself a cluttered mess.
Perhaps because I also use Linux, I have become used to the idea of a screen that only changes when I tell it to. I like the idea that my screen looks less like a hardware review site and more like a book. I don’t want it to shimmer, shine and shake. I want it to be still and quiet like a pond, until I put my hand in.
The UI, particularly in Vista Home Basic which I swear was made only to con you into getting at least Vista Home Premium, is this cluttered mess of animated elements. Everything has an animation to it: you hold the mouse over something and it lights up. Taskbar objects light up as if they are being lit from below with a cheap blue LED. Progress bars constantly pulsate with inner light from left to right even if they are not advancing!
And then there are the popups. Little toaster popups in the bottom right of the screen, wanting this, and demanding that. I used to think XP was bad, but Vista is worse. I suppose this isn’t entirely Vista’s fault. Half of the popups I got when I turned on the Laptop for the first time were from other pieces of software.
For laughs, I counted the number of dialog and toaster pop-ups I encounted in the one hour process of making the computer useful: 47. The trial copy of Norton Internet Security generated more than a dozen all by itself. Some of these are not dialogs the users should ever see like, “Should I disable the Windows firewall and enable the Norton one?” A regular user has no idea what the fuck is that is supposed to mean. Why even ask it?
Vista, for it’s part, requires your attention constantly. The whole User Account Control thing is really driving me up the wall because the shadowed background with the modal “Windows Needs Your Permission…” dialog really breaks you out of the any flow you’ve got going on. This may sound like a simple thing, but because I haven’t yet trained myself to disable it on every new Vista box I see, I am constantly pestered by it and it slows me down because it can sometimes take a few seconds to appear. At least with Linux, the prompt for a root password is… prompt. I’m not even convinced such schemes protects the user all that much anyway. Let’s think about this for a bit. If the user wants :)) FREE SMILEYS!!!! (unbeknown to them infected by spyware), are they really going to contemplate the UAC dialog? No, they are just going to click “Continue”. Of all the new features of Vista this one seems the most pointless and annoys me the most.
I could go on. The new filesystem organization irritates me. Gadgets annoy me and seem of dubious value. The shutdown menu has too many selections. Sure the Task Switcher is cool and the chess game is nice, but such things are superfluous at best.
I don’t think I’m that out of touch with computer users. I can’t believe that bling is what they really want. At the end of the day most users just want computers that do what they are told to do with a minimum of fuss and hassle. They want chat, web, email, media playback and maybe a word processor. Vista does none of these faster or better than XP. It’s pretty, I’ll give it that, but from a functionality standpoint, it is mostly underwhelming.