Freedom and the Olympic Games
Did they put on a great Olympiad? Of course they did. One of the things you can count on when it comes to authoritarian states like China is that the trains will always be on time and the Olympic Games will come off without a hitch. Everyone in the People’s Republic worked hard for it. Either that or the gulag, right? Poor old China seems to generate a lot of bad press these days.
http://www.cbc.ca/olympics/story/2008/08/24/olympics-closing-ceremony-report.html
This is typical of a 2008 Olympiad posting at the CBC. The commenters tend to fall into two camps: the “China can do no wrong” camp or the “China is evil” camp. The first camp are funny to listen to because they are very likely: people living in China who are afraid to speak ill of the government; Chinese people getting paid to do this by the PRC; or Chinese people living in Canada who left China but still inexplicably think it’s the best country on Earth (so why did you leave in the first place?) The second camp are predictable and boring, like most bleeding hearts are. Yes, yes, yes, it is a totalitarian state. So what? Much of the world is. You live here, be thankful.
“German sport has only one task: to strengthen the character of the German people, imbuing it with the fighting spirit and steadfast camaraderie necessary in the struggle for its existence.”
– Joseph Goebbels
Things don’t change that much. Like China at Beijing, Germany won the most gold medals in 1936 at Berlin. ‘36 was considered a great Games in spite of the fact that it also served nicely as Nazi propaganda and not long after the Nazis started the worst war in human history. Now I’m not comparing communists to Nazis, though I do find it interesting that the more screwed up a government is, the more authoritarian it is. Just saying…
My main problem with the Olympics is it has become this crazed nationalistic thing. Maybe it always has been. It’s hard to not get caught up in the excitement, what with cheering for your country and all, but by and large, most people, indeed, most nations, miss the point of the Olympics, seeing it as a way of advancing some kind of national agenda.
China, for example, doesn’t give a shit about amateur sport. Since when does excelling at sport have anything to do with building a great communist society? So why did China host the Olympics? Why does any non-West nation want to do it? To prove to the West that they are awesome. Commies, in particular, have always had this hard-on for proving to the democratic West, specifically the Americans, that they can be awesome too, even if it is somewhat contrary to the goal of a society where everyone is supposed to be equal. Soviet Russia tried to do it for years.
Now as for me, I’m philosophical about the whole thing. I’m a bit of a moral absolutionist so I tend to relate to that second group, but at the same time I am pragmatic. I know there is nothing Canada can really do to change China. There is no military, social or economic force that a nation of 33 million can exert on a nation of 1.3 billion that will be noticed. Hell, there’s nothing the West can do. The people of China outnumber all the people in the Western World nearly 2 to 1.
So what I’m thinking is that maybe we shouldn’t even try to change China. If the Chinese people are really happy with their mobile execution squads, their Tiananmen square massacre, their Great Firewall, their fantastic commie government, and the millions of people that Mao killed, then fine, we got no call to stop ‘em. If a billion proletarians don’t want to rise up to stop it then logically we must be wrong about this whole freedom thing. Maybe that’s just what the Chinese like. As long as they do it over there and not here.
And hey, they put on a pretty good Olympic Games. Good looking stadium; great opening ceremonies. Freedom? This is China and the place is changing all the time. Maybe next year.

When I was 18, I almost joined the CF Reserves because they said I’d get to fire one of 

