This is my edit for the end of BSG. A lot of the ideas they had were good, just played out too long. I personally would have gone for a much shorter, more classic ending. YMMV, this was slammed out real fast, but I have to get it out of my head. I’m not RDM, but I’ll stand by this hack.
The flashbacks are okay, but I would have wound them all up before the final ending. The final ending goes down with all the gun fights but when it all gets bad Cavil orders all of his remaining Basestars to destroy the Galactica. Galactica gets away in the nick of time as the Basestars jump in. The nukes go off and the extreme amount of debris and gravity shear destroys them and plunges them all into the black hole. If you are going to have a black hole in a sci-fi show it might as well be a hungry one, even if this is not so realistic. Classic baddies get what they deserve.
The last bits are tied together with narration.
Galactica jumps into orbit around Earth, her back broken, never able to jump again. It is Earth. Lush and beautiful. They have made it. At the CIC Starbuck realises that Sam is dying along with Galactica. Admiral Adama narrates as she holds him and cries. Sam has agreed to take Galactica into to Sun to dispose of it and himself; the rest of the fleet is to be stripped down and used to start off developing the Earth. Sam whispers, “I’ll see you on the other side,” as she leaves him.
From there more narration and a focus on starting over, forgiveness, thankfulness and family. Dr. Cottle tells Romo about the primitive conditions that will result, even with what’s left of the fleet. Romo replies, as he plays with his dog, that he had been looking forward to a more simple life anyway (starting over). Helen narrates as Admiral Yoshi releases the remaining Red Stripe Centurions and allows them to go on their way in the Rebel Basestar. Yoshi and his staff salute them and they salute back (forgiveness). A montage of the vast amounts of life on the world, interspersed with happy civilians, Cylons and crew (thankfulness). Helo and Sharon happily running through the grass with Hera (the family).
Baltar and Six along with their Angels are told of their part. They look at Sharon, Helo and Hera from on top a hill and ask if this breaks the cycle and the Angels reply they don’t know for sure, but it looks promising; they leave. Six asks Baltar what he was planning on doing, and he replies, “Farming. I know how to farm and it seems like an honest trade.” They leave holding hands, “I don’t know anything about farming,” she says. “It’s not that complex once you get the hang of it…”
Yoshi gives the Admiral back his bars while Tigh, Galen and Ellen look on. He says they were never really his, plus he is planning on retiring anyway, perhaps to raise horses; he leaves. The Admiral shakes Tigh and Tyrol’s hands and briefly hugs Ellen. He says it was a pleasure to have served with them all. They ask Galen what he’s going to do and he says he doesn’t know, maybe go north. “So what are you going to do now, Bill?” Tigh asks. “See about a cabin.”
The Admiral boards a Raptor where Roslin is waiting. She is clearly sick, but he takes her to the future location of the cabin they had planned together. He holds her as they sit on the hillside, watching herds of buffalo and she declares that it is beautiful. She is now too weak to move. He holds her close for a while until he realizes she has died.
Somewhere else, Lee and Starbuck shoot the breeze for a minute or two before she blurts out that she’s pretty certain that she’s done what she came back to do. She kisses Lee on the cheek and says she has to go now. She leaves him and begins to walk. He turns away at first, but then says, “But what if you stay….” As he looks back she is gone. poof, gone. I liked that bit.
Bill Adama comes up. Without anything being said Lee knows that Roslin has died, so he says that “She had to leave,” refering to Starbuck. The Admiral understands too and asks what Lee has planned. He’ll explore the planet, he says, but do you need help with that cabin? Bill puts his arm around his son and they leave the stage. This is the end of the show.
Obviously there would be more dialog than this, but we are talking about a 10 min wrapup — tops. I care little for the idea that the Colonials become our ancestors. This hardly matters. Why leave it like I say? The Adama’s were sort of at odds at the beginning of the show, but during the course of it they accepted each other and went their own ways. The show kinda focused a bit on family anyway, so why not? Also, these two core characters have lost someone special, but they still have each other. You can choose to focus on any number of stories in the show run, but this one is the most enduring, the love of a father and son and all the possibilities of them working together to build a new world. Will the ‘Cycle’ be broken? Doesn’t matter, really, audience is left to decide whether our good guys have broke the cycle and will survive in their new lives.